SaaS Critique

Home / Reviews / Email marketing

Substack review (2026): The easiest way to start a newsletter and get paid, and the hardest to outgrow cheaply.

Substack lets writers, podcasters and video creators publish a newsletter and website for free, then charge for subscriptions while Substack takes 10% plus payment fees. Its app, Notes and Recommendations help new readers find you, but it offers little design control, automation or segmentation compared with email marketing platforms.

GAdd SaaS Critique as a preferred source on Google

SaaS Critique is free to read. Some vendors pay for sponsored placements in our best lists, which helps fund the site. Payment never changes a score or a verdict, and we cover products whether or not they pay us. How we score.

7.2/10Try firstThe easiest way to start a newsletter and get paid, and the hardest to outgrow cheaply.

Key takeaways

  • Best for: writers starting a free or paid newsletter with built-in discovery.
  • Price: Free; 10% of paid subscription revenue.
  • Buy it if: You are a writer or creator starting out, want to publish for free or test paid subscriptions without any setup, and value discovery through Substack's network.
  • Skip it if: You run a business newsletter that needs automation, segmentation, branding or a custom sending domain, or your paid revenue is already large enough that a 10% cut outweighs a flat-fee platform.

Email marketingSubstack at a glance

Pros

  • Free to publish with no subscriber or send limits
  • Paid subscriptions, free trials, founding member tiers, group and gift subscriptions built in
  • Notes, Recommendations and the Substack app bring readers from inside the network
  • Newsletters, podcasts, video and livestreams in one place
  • You can export your subscriber list as a CSV

Cons

  • Substack keeps 10% of paid revenue with no cap, on top of payment fees
  • Very little control over design and site structure
  • No email automation beyond a welcome email, and no real segmentation
  • Emails send from a substack.com address, with no custom sending domain
  • Support is form-based and widely criticised

What Substack is

Substack is a publishing platform for newsletters, podcasts and video, with built-in paid subscriptions. Each publication gets a website and an email list, and every post can go to readers' inboxes, the web and the Substack app at the same time. Writers can make posts free or paid-only and set their own prices.

Over time Substack has become a social network as much as an email tool. Notes is a short-form feed inside the app, Recommendations let publications promote each other, and since January 2026 there is a TV app for Apple TV and Google TV with video posts and livestreams. That network is the main thing Substack offers that traditional email marketing platforms do not.

Who Substack is for

Substack is designed for independent writers, journalists, podcasters and creators who want to build a direct audience and, often, earn from subscriptions. Its own showcase includes solo writers who turned newsletters into full-time income and media start-ups that grew into larger organisations.

It is a poor fit for businesses that use email for marketing: there is no automation, no lead capture beyond a subscribe form, limited segmentation and no control over sending domains. Companies sending product updates, promotions or onboarding sequences should use an email marketing tool.

Key features

The editor is clean and simple, with support for images, embeds, audio and video. Posts can be free, paid or partly paywalled, and Sections let readers opt into specific parts of a publication. Monetisation is flexible: monthly and annual plans, a higher founding member tier, free trials, group subscriptions and gift subscriptions are all built in, with billing handled through Stripe.

Discovery is the standout. Recommendations from other publications, Notes and the app's feeds can bring in subscribers who would never have found a standalone newsletter. Reviewers consistently call this a real growth channel, though it also means part of your reach depends on Substack's algorithms.

Substack also covers podcasting and video, including private podcast feeds for paid subscribers, video posts and livestreams. Creators can run community features such as group chats for subscribers. Analytics cover opens, clicks, subscriber growth and revenue, which TechRadar describes as basic.

In 2026 Substack added developer access in the form of a read-only API for public profile data and an MCP server, but neither can send email. There is still only one automated message, the welcome email, and no triggers, sequences or behaviour-based flows.

Pricing explained

For a free newsletter, Substack costs nothing, at any size. That makes it one of the cheapest ways to send to a large list, since email platforms usually charge by subscriber count.

For paid newsletters, the cost is a share of revenue rather than a subscription. This is low risk when you are starting, because you pay nothing until readers pay you. It becomes expensive as you grow: a writer earning $200,000 a year in subscriptions gives Substack about $20,000 of it before payment fees.

Ease of use and setup

Substack is about as easy as publishing gets. You create an account, name your publication and start writing; turning on paid subscriptions means connecting a Stripe account and choosing prices. There are no templates to design, domains to verify or lists to configure.

The trade-off is control. Reviewers from TechRadar and SMTPedia both point to limited customisation of the site and emails, weak SEO features and few options for layout. Writers who care about a distinctive brand or a full website usually pair Substack with another tool or move to Ghost or WordPress.

Integrations

Substack has very few integrations by design. You can import an existing list, connect Stripe for payments and add a custom domain for the website, and subscriber data can be exported as a CSV including plan information. There is no Zapier-style integration catalogue and no API for sending.

Exports have limits: SMTPedia notes that subscriber names are not included. Because Stripe customers are connected to your own Stripe account, paid subscribers can be migrated to platforms such as Ghost or beehiiv, which is an important safeguard if you later leave.

Support and reliability

Support runs through a help-centre form, and independent reviewers describe it as a weakness, citing slow responses, chatbots and difficulty reaching a person. SMTPedia notes a 1.4 out of 5 Trustpilot score, mostly from readers complaining about billing.

Substack's publisher agreement allows it to end an account at any time, and senders have no control over SPF, DKIM or DMARC records because mail goes out from Substack's domain. For most writers deliverability is good, but it is outside your control.

What users like and dislike

Writers like that Substack needs no technical knowledge, that monetisation is built in, that they own their subscriber list, and that the network can deliver new readers through recommendations. TechRadar calls it a refreshing alternative to SEO-driven blogging.

The common complaints are the uncapped 10% fee, limited design and branding, weak SEO, no automation or advanced segmentation, dependence on Substack's algorithms for discovery, and poor support. SMTPedia rates it highly for starting a free newsletter and poorly as a long-term email marketing platform.

Our verdict

Substack is the best place for most writers to start: it is free, simple and comes with an audience network no email tool can match. For a newsletter that is free or earning modest subscription revenue, it is hard to beat.

Once paid revenue is substantial, or you need automation, branding or a custom sending domain, compare flat-fee platforms such as beehiiv or Ghost. Your list and paid subscribers can move with you, so starting on Substack is a low-risk choice.

Substack scores 7.2 out of 10 overall. Its strongest criterion is ease of use (9.5/10) and its weakest is room to grow (6/10).

Substack pricing

PlanPriceWhat you get
Free publishing$0Unlimited subscribers and sends for free newsletters, podcasts and video
Paid subscriptions10% of revenueSubstack's fee on each paid subscription transaction
Stripe processing2.9% + $0.30 per chargeCard fees for a US Stripe account, plus 0.7% Stripe Billing fee on recurring subscriptions
Custom domain$50 one-timeUse your own web address for the publication site

Substack has no monthly plans. Publishing is free at any size; you only pay when readers pay you. Substack takes 10% of each paid subscription, Stripe charges 2.9% plus 30 cents per card transaction for a US account, and Stripe Billing adds 0.7% on recurring subscriptions. Readers pay no extra fees.

Together the fees come to roughly 13.6% of gross revenue on typical subscriptions, and there is no ceiling. A publication with 1,000 paying readers at $8 a month grosses $96,000 a year and keeps about $83,000, so roughly $13,000 goes to Substack and Stripe. Small prices are hit hardest by the fixed 30-cent fee, so annual plans are more efficient than monthly ones.

A custom domain costs a one-time $50, and you buy the domain itself from a registrar. It changes the website address only; emails still send from a substack.com address. Stripe fees vary by country and payment method, for example SEPA Direct Debit and Bancontact in Europe have their own rates.

Flat-fee platforms such as beehiiv, Kit or Ghost charge a monthly subscription instead of a revenue share. Independent reviewers suggest comparing them once paid revenue passes roughly $40,000 a year, because from that point a fixed fee is often cheaper than 10%.

Prices in US dollars, checked on Nov 21, 2026. Confirm on Substack's own site before you buy.

Buy it ifYou are a writer or creator starting out, want to publish for free or test paid subscriptions without any setup, and value discovery through Substack's network.

How we scored Substack

CriterionScoreWhy
Value for money (25%)7Free for unpaid newsletters and nothing up front for paid ones, but the uncapped 10% cut becomes expensive as revenue grows.
Features (25%)6.5Strong monetisation and network discovery, but almost no automation, segmentation, testing or design control.
Ease of use (20%)9.5One of the simplest ways to publish: no templates, domains or payment setup needed beyond connecting Stripe.
Room to grow (15%)6Handles huge audiences, yet growing publishers hit limits on branding, data, automation and deliverability control.
Support and trust (15%)7Writers own their list and can export it, but support is weak and the publisher agreement lets Substack end accounts at its discretion.

Alternatives to Substack

  • beehiiv: Choose it for a newsletter platform with flat pricing, automations, ad network and stronger growth tools.
  • Ghost: Choose it for a full branded website with memberships and no revenue share.
  • Kit: Choose it for creator email marketing with automations, sequences and paid newsletters.
  • Patreon: Choose it for memberships across many content types beyond writing.
  • Mailchimp: Choose it for business email marketing with templates, segmentation and automations.

Substack FAQs

How much does Substack cost?

Publishing on Substack is free. If you charge for subscriptions, Substack keeps 10% of paid revenue, and Stripe charges card fees (2.9% plus 30 cents in the US) plus a 0.7% recurring billing fee.

Does Substack charge for free newsletters?

No. There are no fees for free publications, whatever the number of subscribers or emails sent.

Can I use my own domain on Substack?

Yes, for a one-time $50 fee, using a domain you buy separately. Emails still send from a substack.com address.

Can I leave Substack and take my subscribers?

Yes. You can export your subscriber list as a CSV, and because paid subscriptions run through your own Stripe account, they can be migrated to other platforms.

Does Substack have email automation?

Only a welcome email. There are no sequences, triggers or behavioural automations, so businesses needing them should use an email marketing platform.

Is Substack good for business newsletters?

Usually not. It lacks branding control, segmentation, automation and a custom sending domain, which most business email programmes need.

Sources

Checked on 2026-11-21. This is a desk review based on the sources below and published user feedback, not a long-term hands-on test.

Why you can trust SaaS Critique

Every product on SaaS Critique is scored on the same five criteria with the same weights, and each review ends with who should not buy it. We work from vendors' public pricing pages, plan tables, documentation and patterns in published user feedback. Unless a review says otherwise, it is a desk review rather than a long-term hands-on test.

Some best lists include sponsored placements. A sponsored placement is a position in a list. It never changes a product's score, its verdict or what we say about its weaknesses.

Our methodology
  • Value for money (25%). What you pay against what you get, including the plan most teams end up on.
  • Features (25%). How much of the job the product covers without add-ons.
  • Ease of use (20%). How quickly a new person can do useful work in it.
  • Room to grow (15%). Whether it still works when the team and the workload double.
  • Support and trust (15%). Support quality, pricing stability and how the vendor treats customers.

Overall score of 8.0 or more: Buy. 6.5 to 7.9: Try first. Below 6.5: Skip. Read the full method.

Compare Substack with

Nathan Brooks

About the author

Nathan Brooks

Editor, SaaS Critique

Nathan edits SaaS Critique and writes our best lists and reviews of business software for small and mid-sized teams. He checks every list against vendors' current pricing pages and holds each product to the same five-part scoring method, so every verdict can be compared with the next.