SaaS Critique

Home / Reviews / Payroll

OnPay review (2026): One plan, everything in, fair price.

OnPay is full-service US payroll at one price: $49 a month plus $6 per worker covers unlimited pay runs, federal, state and local tax filings, multi-state payroll, W-2s and 1099s and contractor payments. Optional HR and time tracking add-ons are cheap, and support is highly rated, though HR tools are lighter than Gusto's or Rippling's.

GAdd SaaS Critique as a preferred source on Google

SaaS Critique is free to read. Some vendors pay for sponsored placements in our best lists, which helps fund the site. Payment never changes a score or a verdict, and we cover products whether or not they pay us. How we score.

8.1/10BuyOne plan, everything in, fair price.

Key takeaways

  • Best for: Best value full-service payroll.
  • Price: $49/mo + $6 per worker.
  • Buy it if: You run a US small business and want complete, reliable payroll with tax filings at a predictable price.
  • Skip it if: You want payroll, HR and IT in one platform with deep performance and recruiting tools, or you employ people abroad.

PayrollOnPay at a glance

Pros

  • One transparent plan with tax filings, multi-state payroll and year-end forms included
  • Unlimited pay runs, including off-cycle and bonus runs
  • Specialist handling for farms, restaurants, nonprofits and churches
  • Cheap HR and time tracking add-ons
  • Free setup and data migration, and the first month free for new customers

Cons

  • HR tools are lighter than Gusto, Paycor or Rippling
  • No international payroll
  • Employer mobile experience is weaker than desktop
  • Support is weekdays only, with no weekend cover

What OnPay is

OnPay is a US payroll, HR and benefits platform for small and mid-sized businesses. Its core product runs payroll, calculates and files federal, state and local payroll taxes, produces W-2s and 1099s and pays employees by direct deposit, debit card or printed check.

What makes OnPay different is its pricing. Instead of three or four tiers, it offers one payroll plan with everything included, plus optional HR and time tracking add-ons. That makes the bill easy to predict and avoids the common trap of upgrading just to pay employees in another state.

Who OnPay is for

OnPay suits US small businesses from a handful of employees to a few hundred, especially those with staff in several states, a mix of employees and contractors, or industry-specific tax needs. FitSmallBusiness highlights specialist handling for farms (including Form 943 and H-2A workers), restaurants (tip credits and Form 8846), nonprofits and churches (including clergy parsonage allowances).

It is a weaker fit if you need international payroll, payroll in US territories, or a full HR suite with recruiting, performance reviews and learning. Fast-growing companies that want payroll, HR and IT on one record may prefer Rippling.

Key features

Payroll runs are unlimited, including off-cycle and bonus payments, and OnPay supports multiple pay schedules, multiple pay rates, tips and multi-state employees. It files and pays payroll taxes and offers a guarantee covering penalties caused by its own filing errors. Direct deposit typically takes two or four days.

Contractors can be paid through the same system, with 1099s produced at year end. Employee self-service lets staff onboard themselves, view pay stubs and tax forms and request time off. PTO policies support custom rules and automatic accruals, including tiers based on seniority or location.

Benefits integrations connect health insurance from major carriers, 401(k) plans from providers such as Guideline and Vestwell, and pay-as-you-go workers' compensation, with deductions applied automatically each pay run. OnPay does not offer earned wage access or pay-on-demand.

The HR add-on adds compliance resources and live HR support through OnPay's partnership with Mineral. A time tracking add-on records hours and feeds them into payroll, and both can be bought together or bundled with payroll at a lower per-worker rate.

Industry-specific payroll

OnPay's specialist tax handling is one of its most practical advantages. For farms, it supports agricultural payroll filings such as Form 943 and H-2A visa workers. For restaurants, it handles tips and the Form 8846 tip credit. Nonprofits get the right FUTA treatment for 501(c)(3) organisations, and churches can pay clergy with parsonage allowances handled correctly.

Many low-cost payroll services either do not support these situations or push them to a higher tier. If you run one of these types of organisation, OnPay is worth shortlisting even before you compare prices.

OnPay also suits seasonal businesses. Because the $6 fee applies only to workers paid in a given month, a business that employs 20 people in summer and five in winter pays for five in the quiet months. One Capterra reviewer would still like an option to suspend the account entirely during inactive periods.

Pricing explained

The base plan costs $49 a month plus $6 per worker paid. Everything payroll-related is included: unlimited runs, all tax filings, year-end forms, multi-state payroll, contractor payments and expert support by phone, chat and email.

HR costs $15 a month plus $2 per worker on top, or you can choose a bundle that combines payroll and HR at $71 a month plus $1 per worker. Time tracking is available alone or bundled. Because there is only one payroll plan, the main decision is whether you need the HR add-on.

Ease of use and setup

OnPay offers free setup and data migration, which removes much of the pain of switching mid-year. Reviewers describe the dashboard as intuitive and say a typical payroll run takes only a few minutes.

Some users want more automation, such as fully automatic recurring payroll runs or the ability to edit a submitted pay run, and several reviewers say the employer mobile experience is weak compared with the desktop app.

Integrations

OnPay integrates with QuickBooks Online and Xero for accounting, Deputy, When I Work and QuickBooks Time for scheduling and time tracking, Guideline and Vestwell for 401(k), and Mineral and PosterElite for HR compliance.

The catalogue is smaller than Gusto's, and some reviewers mention occasional integration glitches and a QuickBooks sync that is less complete than they wanted. Check that your accounting and time tools are supported before switching.

Support and reliability

Support is available by phone, chat and email on weekdays, with FitSmallBusiness listing hours of 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern. There is no weekend or 24/7 support, which matters if you run payroll outside business hours.

Capterra reviewers rate customer service 4.8 out of 5 and often praise knowledgeable live support during onboarding. A few report slow resolution of tax form corrections or a missed state tax payment that led to penalties, so keep an eye on tax notices in the first few months.

What users like and dislike

OnPay holds 4.8 out of 5 on Capterra from about 470 reviews. Users praise the all-in-one plan, transparent pricing, ease of use, handling of contractors and multi-state payroll, and responsive support.

Common complaints are the weak employer mobile app, fewer integrations and lighter reporting than larger providers, limits on automation, and mixed views on the time tracking features.

Our verdict

OnPay is the best-value full-service payroll for most US small businesses. One plan covers everything a typical company needs, including multi-state payroll, and the price stays predictable as you grow. Specialist tax handling makes it particularly strong for farms, restaurants, nonprofits and churches.

If you want a broader HR platform with performance management, recruiting and device management, or you hire abroad, look at Gusto, Rippling or Deel instead. For straightforward payroll done well, OnPay is hard to beat.

Where OnPay ranks

OnPay scores 8.1 out of 10 overall. Its strongest criterion is value for money (9/10) and its weakest is room to grow (7/10).

OnPay pricing

PlanPriceWhat you get
Payroll Essentials$49/mo + $6 per workerUnlimited pay runs, all tax filings, multi-state, W-2s and 1099s, contractor payments
HR add-on$15/mo + $2 per workerCompliance resources and live HR support
HR + Time Tracking add-on$21/mo + $4 per workerHR tools plus time tracking
Bundled HR$71/mo + $1 per workerPayroll and HR bundled
Bundled HR + Time Tracking$81/mo + $4 per workerPayroll, HR and time tracking bundled

OnPay's pricing page lists one payroll plan at $49 a month plus $6 per worker, with HR and time tracking as optional add-ons or bundles. There are no implementation or integration fees, and new customers get setup, data migration and the first month free.

You pay only for workers paid in a given month, so seasonal businesses are not charged for staff who are not working. Benefits administration is free; you pay only the insurance or 401(k) premiums.

Smaller extra charges exist. FitSmallBusiness reports $9.99 per W-2 or 1099 if OnPay mails the forms, a fee for insufficient funds and $20 for a live call with Mineral HR experts.

At typical sizes, a five-person team pays $79 a month for payroll, a 15-person team $139 and a 30-person team $229. Adding the HR add-on raises those to $104, $184 and $304. That is generally cheaper than Gusto's middle tier for the same headcount, especially for multi-state employers.

Prices in US dollars, checked on Nov 21, 2026. Confirm on OnPay's own site before you buy.

Buy it ifYou run a US small business and want complete, reliable payroll with tax filings at a predictable price.

How we scored OnPay

CriterionScoreWhy
Value for money (25%)9$49 plus $6 per worker includes multi-state payroll and filings that rivals often reserve for higher tiers.
Features (25%)8Payroll, tax, contractors, PTO and benefits integrations are strong; HR depth is limited without the add-on.
Ease of use (20%)8Reviewers consistently describe an intuitive dashboard and payroll runs that take minutes.
Room to grow (15%)7Works well up to mid-sized teams, but lacks the HR breadth and enterprise controls of larger platforms.
Support and trust (15%)8Transparent pricing with no implementation fees, a tax penalty guarantee and highly rated support.

Alternatives to OnPay

  • Gusto: Choose it for a more polished interface and broader built-in HR and benefits tools.
  • Patriot Payroll: Choose it if price matters most and you can live with basic features.
  • Rippling: Choose it to run payroll, HR, IT and devices on one employee record.
  • ADP RUN: Choose it if you want a large provider with HR outsourcing and PEO options.
  • Deel: Choose it if you employ or contract people outside the US.

OnPay FAQs

How much does OnPay cost?

OnPay costs $49 a month plus $6 per worker paid. HR is an optional add-on at $15 a month plus $2 per worker, and bundles with HR and time tracking are available.

Does OnPay file payroll taxes?

Yes. OnPay calculates, files and pays federal, state and local payroll taxes and produces W-2s and 1099s, all included in the base price.

Does OnPay charge extra for multiple states?

No. Payroll for workers in as many states as you need is included in the single plan.

Is there a free trial?

OnPay offers new customers their first month free, along with free setup and data migration.

Can OnPay pay contractors?

Yes. You can pay 1099 contractors through OnPay alongside employees and it prepares their year-end forms.

Does OnPay support international employees?

No. OnPay is US payroll only and does not cover employees abroad or in US territories. Use Deel or a similar global payroll provider for those workers.

Sources

Checked on 2026-11-21. This is a desk review based on the sources below and published user feedback, not a long-term hands-on test.

Why you can trust SaaS Critique

Every product on SaaS Critique is scored on the same five criteria with the same weights, and each review ends with who should not buy it. We work from vendors' public pricing pages, plan tables, documentation and patterns in published user feedback. Unless a review says otherwise, it is a desk review rather than a long-term hands-on test.

Some best lists include sponsored placements. A sponsored placement is a position in a list. It never changes a product's score, its verdict or what we say about its weaknesses.

Our methodology
  • Value for money (25%). What you pay against what you get, including the plan most teams end up on.
  • Features (25%). How much of the job the product covers without add-ons.
  • Ease of use (20%). How quickly a new person can do useful work in it.
  • Room to grow (15%). Whether it still works when the team and the workload double.
  • Support and trust (15%). Support quality, pricing stability and how the vendor treats customers.

Overall score of 8.0 or more: Buy. 6.5 to 7.9: Try first. Below 6.5: Skip. Read the full method.

Compare OnPay with

Nathan Brooks

About the author

Nathan Brooks

Editor, SaaS Critique

Nathan edits SaaS Critique and writes our best lists and reviews of business software for small and mid-sized teams. He checks every list against vendors' current pricing pages and holds each product to the same five-part scoring method, so every verdict can be compared with the next.